• Baked Fresh Daily

    Add a Second Pie or Cake for No Additional Shipping

Cakes and Cheese Cakes

9" Pan - 4 lbs! Shipped frozen, arrives fresh!

When we set out to make the best cheesecake around, little did we know we would end up with so many delectable flavors! Of course, it’s hard not to come up with winners with such fantastic ingredients.Our carrot cakes will be the hit of any party you take them to, and you better have a good hiding spot at home or they’ll disappear before you know it.


Cakes and Cheesecakes are available for shipping seasonally.

Grand Traverse Pie Company Delivery $16.99 shipping for any 2 day and ground package. Send 2 pies together for NO ADDITIONAL shipping!

Chocolate Peppermint Cheesecake

A Holiday favorite! Our amazing peppermint cheesecake in an Oreo crumb crust. All of this covered in our handmade chocolate Ganache and topped with crushed candy canes to set the stage! The candy cane pieces are seasonal.

QTY 39.99

Pumpkin Swirl Cheesecake

Our creation is made by swirling our very own creamy pumpkin pie filling into the cheesecake batter!  The resulting combined flavor is simply outstanding.  It's perfect for the Holidays!

QTY 39.99

Mom's Carrot Cake

This cake is loaded with carrots, coconut, pecans & pineapple. Then topped with a thick buttermilk glaze and a thick layer of cream cheese frosting.

QTY 36.99

Turtle Cheesecake

In our version of this cheesecake classic we top our cheesecake with toasted pecans and drizzle with Michigan made Morley caramel and Dutch chocolate.  It's the ultimate treat!

QTY 39.99

Gourmet Cheesecake

Taste how each of our cheesecakes start out. This cheesecake cake takes traditional cheesecake to a new level. Enjoy this with a topping of your own or just take in the taste of an amazing classic.

QTY 39.99

Oreo Cheesecake

Oreo's are everywhere in this baby!  We blend them into the crust, mix them into the smooth creamy filling and top with - you guessed it - Oreo's and sour cream!  Don’t forget the big glass of milk with this one!

QTY 39.99