• Remembering All Our Heroes

    Order by May 23rd for
    Memorial Weekend

  • Baked Fresh Daily

    Add a second Pie or Cake for No Additional shipping

  • Give the fresh taste of Michigan fruit

  • Chocolate Sout Pie
    is Back!

    Order by June 13th for
    Father's Day

  • All American
    Apple Pie

    Enjoy any of our classics!

  • Wayne Hill Cherry Ganache

    A GT Pie Exclusive!

     

Fruit Pies

Full Size Fruit Pies - Deep 9" Pan!

From our Front Street Apple Pie to our Farmers Market Peach to our Lakeshore Berry, we have every berry and every combination for every pie lover!  As always, we use only the freshest ingredients and speediest shipping to make sure your Grand Traverse Pie experience is the next best thing to eating one right in our shop! These delicious pies are shipped fresh and ready to eat and come in a keepsake logoed pie tin!

We can make sugar free pastry topped pies in any variety. We use Splenda for a sweetener allowing diabetics to still enjoy a great pie! Call 866-444-7437 to order a Splenda pie that you do not see online.

A delicious personalized pie
 
PERSONALIZE YOUR PIES
We can personalize your Fruit pies like no one else can! Add any 10 character message on top. We can personalize any of our pastry or crumb top pies except for the Apple Crumb with Caramel and Pecans. For only $5 you can add a personalized message with cut outs of our famous pie crust!

$15.99 shipping for any 2 day and ground package. Send 2 pies or cakes together for NO ADDITIONAL shipping!

Old Mission Cherry

Tasty Montmorency cherries fill this pie with a tangy deliciousness-baked in our flaky crust. Featured on Oprah Magazine's "O List." A scrumptious local Northern Michigan favorite, named after one of the most beautiful peninsulas near Traverse City.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Grand Traverse Cherry Crumb

Our top selling pie made with Montmorency cherries. “I don’t think I’ve ever had as good a pie as Grand Traverse Pie Company’s Cherry Crumb Pie... It’s a religious experience.” — Mario Batali, The Food Network. Also the signature pie of the National Cherry Festival in Traverse City.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
State Theater Cherry Peach Crumb

This pie is loaded with Michigan Montmorency cherries and sweet peaches then finished with our amazing toasty crumb topping. A local favorite pie named after our local favorite theater.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Lighthouse Cherry Apple Crumb

Michigan is known for it's lighthouses so we make this blend of Michigan Montmorency cherries and tree ripened Northern Spy apples and then finish it with our toasty crumb topping. A Mouth watering pie! Our shining light!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Long Lake Cherry Berry

A delicious blend of Michigan Montmorency cherries and juicy raspberries in our flaky crust. Seemed right to name this pie after one of Northern Michigan's most beautiful lakes.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Splenda Michigan Cherry

Sugar free! Sweetened with Splenda and still includes our Michigan Montmorency cherries. Sweets for all needs from GT Pie Co. A splendid diabetic option indeed!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Michigan ABC

Michigan Northern Spy Apples, Michigan Rubel blueberries, Michigan Montmorency Cherries finished with our flaky handmade crust-the essence of pure Michigan.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Michigan ABC Crumb

Michigan Northern Spy Apples, Michigan Rubel blueberries, Michigan Montmorency Cherries-Pure Michigan through and through. Finished with our toasty crumb topping.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Front Street Apple

Front Street is where our original shop first opened it's doors! Michigan grown Northern Spy Apples make this a good choice any time of year. Our handmade flaky pastry tops it off!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Peninsula Apple Crumb

Named for our many peninsulas in Northern Michigan. Filled with Michigan orchard picked, sun ripened Northern Spy apples tossed with cinnamon and sugar, finished with our toasty crumb topping.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Leland Apple Crumb with Caramel & Pecans

Starts with our Peninsula Apple Crumb pie then we add toasted pecans with Michigan made Sanders caramel drizzled on top to make a finale' so tempting to the taste buds! A warm summer treat in honor of this cozy little town.

QTY 26.99

 
Splenda Michigan Apple

Sugar free! Sweetened with Splenda and features our Northern Spy Michigan apples all made in our flaky pastry crust. Sweets for all needs from GT Pie Co. A splendid diabetic option indeed!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Suttons Bay Blueberry

This pie is bursting with summer sweet, plump Michigan Rubel blueberries in our flaky pastry crust. Reminds us of the sweet summer atmosphere of Suttons Bay Michigan.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
West Bay Blueberry Crumb

This pie is jam packed with summer sweet, plump Michigan Rubel blueberries. The blues never tasted so good when topped with our toasty crumb topping. This pie tastes as good as the blue waters of West Bay looks!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Splenda Michigan Blueberry

Sugar free! Sweetened with Splenda and features Michigan Rubel blueberries. Sweets for all needs from GT Pie Co. A splendid diabetic option indeed!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Opera House Blueberry Peach

Mix plump Michigan Rubel blueberries with our sweet peaches together and we have a pie so happy we can hear it singing from the rafters like the Traverse City Opera House!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Fire House Strawberry Rhubarb

It's a marriage between sweetness and tartness as strawberries and rhubarb come together to form a most perfect pie. Handmade in our flaky pastry crust this pie is in honor of the fireman across the street from our original location!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
North Bar Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb

Mixing the tart and the sweet with our toasted crumb topping makes this a sweetie pie to try. Nothing says summer like this classic combination. Jump off and dive into this classic summer combination!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Riverside Blackberry

Rich, plump blackberries stuffed into our flaky, pastry dough and topped with more of the same. Remembering those canoe trips and finding blackberries along your travels...

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Tall Ship Blackberry Peach Crumb

Sweet peaches and rich blackberries fill this pie, then its finished with our toasty crumb topping. Every time you take a bite, think of the tall ships that cover Grand Traverse Bay all summer long.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Farmer's Market Peach

Sweet peaches, brown sugar and vanilla baked to perfection with cinnamon and sugar sprinkled on top of our flaky crust sprinkled. Enjoy with a scoop of ice cream for a heavenly treat, biting into these crisp peaches will have you pinning for summer farmer's markets.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Glen Haven Peach Crumb

A golden filling of luscious, tree-ripened peaches, brown sugar and vanilla. Baked to perfection finished with our toasty crumb topping. Makes for memories of summer at Glen Haven Beach.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Union Street Peach Strawberry

Sweet peaches and ripe red strawberries in our flaky crust makes this pie a perfect, mouth watering combination! Brings back memories of being in the heart of downtown Traverse City.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Lakeshore Berry

Brimming with juicy berries picked at the height of the season, this is our mix of strawberries, raspberries, blackberries and Michigan Spy apples with our flaky pastry top. This pie pops with fresh flavors of the Great Lakes.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Lakeshore Berry Crumb

Juicy berries picked at the height of the season, a mix of strawberries, raspberries, blackberries and Michigan Spy apples with our toasty crumb topping. This pie pops with flavor and love from Michigan.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Mountain Berry Crumb

This very popular blend of Michigan Rubel blueberries, raspberries, blackberries, ripe red strawberries in our flaky crust. The taste bursts with berry flavors and then our fabulous toasted crumb topping that we embellish with oatmeal and brown sugar to make this pie extra flavorful. A warm slice of this pie will keep you toasty on any of Michigan's slopes.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Holiday Hill Rhubarb

If you love rhubarb pie you have to try ours. Tangy rhubarb mixed with our sweet filling all in our flaky crust makes this a treat amazing. A fresh taste reminiscent of those brisk walks on Holiday Hill.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Festival Cherry Rhubarb

The National Cherry Festival is a big event in our home town of Traverse City. When the local rhubarb is in season you might find us mixing our Michigan Cherries with rhubarb for a special, seasonal treat.

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Good Harbor Raspberry

Think of rich summer sunsets at Good Harbor Beach. Plump red raspberries in a sweet filling and our flaky crust with a pastry topping. If you love raspberries this ones for you!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE
Leelanau Raspberry Apple Crumb

Leelanau is a beautiful Up North Michigan treat and so is this pie. We blend plump red raspberries with Michigan Northern Spy apples and finish it with our toasty crumb topping!

QTY 26.99

 
PERSONALIZE PIE