• All pies arrive fresh baked and ready to serve

    Serve it up warm!

  • Exclusively Michigan Cherries

    Enjoy what Northern Michigan Has to offer!

Cherry Pies

We exclusively use Michigan cherries - Deep 9" Pan!

Homemade cherry pies are the pies that made us famous. We use only the finest Montmorency cherries for our homemade cherry pies...and why not? Northern Michigan is famous for growing the finest cherries in the world! Combined with a made-from-scratch pie crust and only the best ingredients available; we’ve created homemade cherry pies by which all others cherry pies can be measured!

"I just received your wonderful Cherry Pie! Thank you for having a true filling, not a cornstarch red glob with a few cherries. I know I am loved by the person who sent it!"
- Winter Springs, Florida

A delicious personalized pie


We can personalize your Fruit pies like no one else can! Add any 10 character message on top. We can personalize any of our pastry or crumb top pies except for the Apple Crumb with Caramel and Pecans. For only $5 you can add a personalized message with cut outs of our famous pie crust!

$15.99 shipping for any 2 day and ground package. Send 2 pies or cakes together for NO ADDITIONAL shipping!

Grand Traverse Cherry Crumb

Our top selling pie made with Montmorency cherries. “I don’t think I’ve ever had as good a pie as Grand Traverse Pie Company’s Cherry Crumb Pie... It’s a religious experience.” — Mario Batali, The Food Network. Also the signature pie of the National Cherry Festival in Traverse City.

QTY 26.99

Old Mission Cherry

Tasty Montmorency cherries fill this pie with a tangy deliciousness-baked in our flaky crust. Featured on Oprah Magazine's "O List." A scrumptious local Northern Michigan favorite, named after one of the most beautiful peninsulas near Traverse City.

QTY 26.99

State Theater Cherry Peach Crumb

This pie is loaded with Michigan Montmorency cherries and sweet peaches then finished with our amazing toasty crumb topping. A local favorite pie named after our local favorite theater.

QTY 26.99

Wayne Hill Cherry Ganache

You can't find this pie anywhere else! Our classic Grand Traverse Cherry Crumb Pie is topped with our homemade ganache and features Michigan cherries. This crowd pleaser is sure to become a favorite for those chocolate lovers especially when it's served warmed up!

QTY 28.99

Splenda Michigan Cherry

Sugar free! Sweetened with Splenda and still includes our Michigan Montmorency cherries. Sweets for all needs from GT Pie Co. A splendid diabetic option indeed!

QTY 26.99