• Made Fresh Daily!

    Add a Second Pie or Cake for No Additional Shipping

Cream Pies

Deep 9" Pan! Shipped Frozen, arrives fresh!

Remember the days when you could go into your favorite diner for a slice of your favorite cream pie and you just knew it would be a heavenly experience? Real cream fillings (with real butter!) and a fantastic crust and maybe a hot cup-a-joe to wash it down. Those were the good ole days!

Our cream pies carry on the tradition of the ever-popular homemade cream pies! Just one bite of our cream pies will transport you back to a place in time where the cream was real, the coffee was strong, and the pie was out of this world! But don’t take our word for it - a Grand Traverse Pie Company Cream Pie has to be experienced to be truly appreciated!

Grand Traverse Pie Company Delivery $16.99 shipping for any 2 day and ground package. Send 2 pies together for NO ADDITIONAL shipping!

PetosKEY Lime

Made with real Key Lime juice, each pie has a cream tart filling topped with fluffy, whipped topping rosettes in a delicious graham cracker crust. The crystal blue waters of Petoskey make us feel like we have our own Key West!

QTY 36.99

Old Town Chocolate Cream

Made with fresh milk, butter and eggs like the good 'ol days. Our flaky crust below, rich chocolate cream filling finished with whipped topping and chocolate shavings. This pie pays homage to our amazing Old Town Traverse City.

QTY 36.99

Barb's Peanut Butter Chocolate Cream

A popular combination requested often by the owner's mom Barb! This delectable pie starts with our flaky crust then we add a layer of our chocolate cream followed by a layer of peanut butter cream. Then it's all finished with whipped topping and chocolate shavings.  Share this pie with a loved one!

QTY 36.99

Torch Lake Coconut Cream

Our delicious vanilla cream with coconut flakes is loaded into our flaky crust and finished with whipped topping and toasted coconut. This tropical treasure reminds us of all the boating fun on the lake.

QTY 36.99