All Pies

Our classic Apple Pie on the inside but topped off with a hearty cinnamon oatmeal cr...

Our Autumn Harvest Pecan Pie is loaded with rich, gooey filling mixed with an abunda...

Our Chicken Pot Pie is our most popular mealtime pie! This heartwarming 9" pot pie f...

Sweet, tree-ripened Peterson Farms Peaches, brown sugar, and vanilla baked to perfec...

It's a marriage between sweetness and tartness as strawberries and rhubarb come toge...

Front Street is where our original shop first opened its doors in 1996! Michigan-gro...

Taste how each of our cheesecakes starts out. This cheesecake takes traditional chee...

Our top-selling pie made with tart Michigan Montmorency cherries, sweetened up with ...

If you love rhubarb pie you have to try ours. Tangy rhubarb mixed with our sweet fil...

With juicy berries picked at the height of the season, this pie is a mix of strawber...

Leland Apple Crumb Pie starts with our Peninsula Apple Crumb Pie, then we add toaste...

Pure Michigan through and through! Michigan Northern Spy Apples, Michigan Rubel Blue...

What do you get when you combine Michigan Northern Spy Apples, Michigan Rubel Bluebe...

This very popular pie is a blend of Michigan Rubel Blueberries, raspberries, blackbe...

Mixing the tart and the sweet with our toasted crumb topping makes this a sweetie pi...

This American classic features a pumpkin filling that reminds us of the cozy, quaint...

Tasty Michigan Montmorency cherries fill this pie with a tangy deliciousness and bak...

Made with fresh milk, butter, and eggs like the good old days. Old Town Chocolate Cr...

Pick 3 of your favorite 6" mini fruit pies!

More than a piece and less than ...

Pick 3 of your favorite gluten-free 6" mini pies!

Our Gluten-Free Mini Pies ...

  Choose a 3 pack of 6"Chicken pot pies and you can even choose a mini fruit pie for...

This pie is named for our many peninsulas in Northern Michigan. It's filled with Mic...

Made with real Key Lime juice, each pie has a cream tart filling topped with fluffy,...

Sweetened with Splenda and still includes our Michigan Montmorency cherries. Sweets ...

This pie is loaded with Michigan Montmorency cherries and sweet Michigan peaches the...

This pie is bursting with sweet and plump Michigan Rubel Blueberries in our flaky pa...

Our delicious vanilla cream with coconut flakes is loaded into our flaky crust and f...

A Northern version of a Southern classic. Handmade from scratch filling mixed with p...

You can't find this pie anywhere else! Our classic Grand Traverse Cherry Crumb Pie i...

This pie is jam-packed with sweet and plump Michigan Rubel Blueberries. The blues ne...